Odyssey DFX Double Wide 33" Review: a heavy, soft-feeling putter that just keeps things simple on the greens

I’ve been rolling the Odyssey DFX Double Wide 33" for a few weeks now, and I’ll be straight: I didn’t suddenly turn into a tour pro, but my putting numbers did get a bit better. I moved to this putter from a lighter, older mallet that felt a bit dead and twitchy on short putts. The first thing I noticed with the DFX was the weight and the softer strike. It’s got that all-black look, a double-wide head, and a pistol-style oversize grip that immediately feels more stable in the hands.

On the course, the main change for me was consistency on 5–10 footers. I’m not draining everything, but I’m leaving far fewer putts short. The heavier head and the soft insert make it easier to just swing back and through without getting too handsy. If you’re used to super light putters, this will feel quite different. For me, it slowed down my stroke in a good way.

I play about once a week and practice putting in the garden or at the course maybe twice a week, so I’m not exactly obsessive. Even with that casual level, the difference was noticeable. The DFX insert is softer than what I had before, so off-center hits don’t feel harsh, and the ball doesn’t jump off the face. It’s more of a controlled “thud” than a click. That helps on faster greens where you don’t want the ball to race past the hole.

Overall, my first impression is that this putter is pretty solid for someone who likes a bit of weight and wants a simple, no-nonsense look. It’s not magic, and there are pricier models with more tech and adjustability, but in terms of just getting the ball rolling on line with a nice feel, it gets the job done. Definitely not perfect, but for the price point and the feel, it’s a strong option.

On the value side, this putter sits in a kind of middle ground. It’s not bargain-basement cheap, but it’s also not priced like the top-end milled models. For the money, you’re getting a known brand (Odyssey under Callaway), a soft insert, a decent grip, and a simple, effective design. The Amazon rating around 4.8/5 with a few hundred reviews lines up with my experience: most people seem happy with the feel and performance, especially the weight and softness.

Compared to cheaper, no-name putters, the difference is pretty clear. The DFX feels more solid, the insert feels more controlled, and the overall build quality is better. You also get a proper headcover and a warranty. If you’re the kind of golfer who plays a lot, that extra cost is justified. With super cheap putters, I often find the feel inconsistent and the head too light or tinny. This one feels more “serious” without going into crazy price territory.

Compared to higher-end models (like fully milled faces or putters with adjustable weights), the DFX obviously has fewer features. No adjustability, no fancy materials. If you like to tweak your setup or want a very specific sound and feedback, you might feel limited here. But honestly, for most casual and mid-handicap golfers, you don’t really need all that. You need something that sets up square, feels good, and helps your distance control. On that front, this putter does the job well.

So in plain terms: I’d call the value good, not mind-blowing. You’re paying a fair price for a solid, well-known product that performs reliably. There are cheaper options that will work fine, and there are more expensive ones that might feel a bit nicer. But if you want a heavier, soft-feel putter from a big brand without spending top dollar, this DFX Double Wide sits in a pretty sensible spot.

The design is probably one of the main selling points here. It’s full black: black head, black shaft, black grip. On the green, that looks clean and a bit more serious than the shiny chrome stuff. There’s no glare, which I appreciate on sunny days. The head shape is a double-wide blade, so you get a rectangular look that’s longer from face to back than a classic narrow blade. For me, that shape makes it easier to feel where the face is pointing and to keep the putter stable through impact.

Alignment is very straightforward. You get a single white line on the top of the head. No three-line patterns, no circles, nothing busy. If you like a lot of alignment aids, you might find this a bit too bare. Personally, I liked the simplicity. I put the line on the ball, match it with the line on the putter, and go. After a few rounds, I wasn’t thinking about alignment as much, which is a good sign. One Amazon reviewer mentioned it’s “so easy to line up”, and I’d agree with that, as long as you’re okay with a minimal look.

The face insert is black as well, and it blends into the rest of the head. You don’t get the contrast you see on some Odyssey White Hot models. The downside of that is you don’t get a visual cue of where on the face you’re striking the ball. The upside is everything looks clean and unified. The putter has a bit of a stealth look without screaming for attention. It’s not flashy, but it looks modern enough.

One thing I did notice is that the all-black finish will eventually show marks if you’re careless with it. After a couple of rounds, I had a few small scuffs on the sole from sand and cart paths. Nothing dramatic, but it’s not invisible. The top line and face held up fine so far, though. Overall, I’d call the design simple, functional, and confidence-inspiring at address, especially if you like a wider blade but don’t want a full mallet. It’s not a showpiece, but it looks like a tool built to do a job.

Comfort-wise, the first thing you notice is the weight. This putter is on the heavier side, especially compared to the modern ultra-light stuff. One Amazon review even points that out as the best part, and I’m on the same page. With the 33" length and the oversize grip, it feels very stable in the hands. If you tend to get “wristy” or jab at the ball, the weight helps smooth out your stroke. After a couple of sessions, I felt like I was just rocking my shoulders and letting the head do the work, which is exactly what you want.

The oversize pistol grip adds to that comfort. It fills the hands without feeling like a giant foam tube. I used it in light rain, and it didn’t feel slippery. The pistol shape lets you anchor your thumbs along the top and keeps your hands in a neutral position. If you’ve been using a skinny, old-school grip, this will feel thicker, but I adapted quickly. For long practice sessions (30–40 minutes on the putting green), I didn’t feel any strain in the wrists or forearms, which I sometimes get with lighter putters where I end up over-controlling the head.

One thing to be aware of: if you’re used to a lighter putter, the first few holes might feel like you’re hitting everything a bit hard. With the soft insert plus the heavier head, you need to trust the stroke and not “hit” at the ball. Once you relax and just let the pendulum motion happen, it becomes more comfortable. On longer putts, the weight actually helped me maintain a smoother tempo. I had fewer ugly, decelerating strokes where the ball ends up way short.

Overall, I’d say comfort is a strong point of this putter, as long as you like or can adapt to a heavier feel. It’s not fatiguing, the grip is pleasant, and the feedback in the hands is clear without being harsh. If you have very small hands or you hate oversize grips, you might want to try it in person first. But for most casual golfers who want a stable, confidence-boosting feel, it’s pretty well dialed in.

Material-wise, there’s nothing exotic going on, and that’s not a bad thing. The head is alloy steel, which gives it a solid, slightly heavy feel. You can feel the head weight during the stroke, and that’s the main thing I liked about this putter. It doesn’t feel hollow or cheap. When you set it down behind the ball, it feels grounded. The shaft is listed as graphite/steel in some specs but behaves and looks like a black steel shaft in the hand. It’s stiff enough that you don’t feel any wobble, which is what you want in a putter.

The insert is the real talking point. Odyssey calls this their softest insert ever, and I believe that. Compared to my older putter (a mid-priced mallet with a firmer face), the DFX feels noticeably softer. On contact, you get more of a muted “thunk” than a “click”. On fast greens, that’s a plus because the ball doesn’t jump off the face. On slow, shaggy greens, you might feel like you have to hit it a bit harder. Once I adjusted, I actually preferred it, but if you love a very firm, clicky feel, this might not be your thing.

The grip is an oversize rubber pistol grip. It’s not as fat as a SuperStroke 3.0, but it’s thicker than a standard grip. For me, it sits in the hands nicely and helps quiet the wrists. The rubber quality feels decent: slightly tacky, not slippery, even with a bit of sweat. After a few rounds and some practice sessions, I didn’t notice any wear or twisting. It’s not the fanciest grip ever, but it’s more than good enough out of the box, and I didn’t feel the urge to change it immediately.

Overall, the materials feel solid and practical, not premium in a luxury sense but definitely not cheap. You’re paying for a known brand and a proven insert technology rather than exotic metals or carbon fiber. If you want a flashy milled face or adjustable weights, look elsewhere. If you just want a heavier, soft-feeling head with a comfortable grip that works in normal conditions, it hits the mark pretty well.

In terms of durability, I obviously haven’t used it for years, but after several rounds and practice sessions, a few things stand out. The head finish is a matte black that does a decent job hiding minor wear, but it’s not bulletproof. The sole picked up a few light scratches from sand and general use, which is completely normal. The top line and face still look clean, which is what really matters when you’re standing over the ball. I’d say as long as you use the headcover and don’t slam it around in the bag, it should hold up fine.

The shaft feels solid and hasn’t shown any signs of rust, bending, or chipping in the coating so far. I’ve used it in slightly damp conditions and wiped it down after the round, and it still looks like new. It doesn’t feel fragile in any way. The connection between shaft and head is tight, no wobble, no weird noises. That’s basic stuff, but I’ve seen cheaper putters where the head starts to feel loose after a while. No issue like that here.

The rubber grip is holding up well too. I’ve used it with bare hands and with a glove, and it still feels tacky enough. No signs of peeling or excessive wear yet. Over time, any grip will eventually get shiny and might need replacing, but I don’t see that happening quickly with this one. It feels like a standard quality OEM grip from a big brand, which is to say: reliable but not fancy.

Considering it’s made in China but backed by Callaway with a 2-year manufacturer warranty, I’m not too worried about long-term durability. There’s always the chance of a dud, but nothing in my unit suggests cheap construction. If you treat your clubs reasonably well, this putter should easily last several seasons. It’s not some fragile showpiece; it feels like a normal, workhorse putter that can handle regular play without falling apart.

Performance-wise, I mainly care about three things: start line, distance control, and forgiveness on mishits. With this Odyssey DFX Double Wide, the start line has been very solid. The wider blade and the weight make it easier to keep the face square through impact. I noticed fewer pushes and pulls on 6–10 foot putts compared to my old putter. The simple alignment line helps too. It’s nothing fancy, but it works. After a few rounds, I was more confident standing over those mid-range putts, which is already a win.

Distance control took a few sessions to dial in because of the soft insert. The ball comes off the face a bit slower than a firm milled putter, so at first, I left some putts short, especially on slower greens. After that adjustment phase, I actually preferred the softer feel because it gave me more control on fast greens. I wasn’t scared of blowing it 6 feet past anymore. The heavier head also helps you maintain tempo on long putts; you just make a bigger, smoother stroke instead of jabbing at it.

On mishits, the putter is fairly forgiving for a blade-style shape. Heel and toe strikes still lose some distance, obviously, but they don’t feel awful, and the ball doesn’t shoot wildly off line. The double-wide head adds some stability compared to a skinny blade. It’s not as forgiving as a big mallet with huge perimeter weighting, but for its size, it does a decent job. I had a few putts where I knew I caught it slightly off-center and still ended up in tap-in range instead of three-putt territory.

In terms of real impact, I’d say this: over a few rounds, I saw a small but noticeable drop in three-putts and a slight improvement in make percentage inside 10 feet. Nothing crazy, but enough that I feel more relaxed on the greens. It doesn’t fix bad reads or terrible strokes, but it gives you a stable, soft-feeling tool that makes it easier to be consistent. For a mid-handicap or casual golfer, that’s pretty much what you’re looking for. If you’re super picky and want a very firm, precise feedback feel, you might want a milled face instead. For most of us, this is more than good enough.

Out of the box, the package is very basic: you get the putter, a headcover, and that’s it. No fancy extras or adjustment tools or weights. It’s a straightforward, ready-to-play club. The headcover is decent, nothing special, but it protects the all-black head well enough. The putter I tested is the 33" right-handed version with the double-wide head and an oversize pistol grip. It’s built with an alloy steel head, a black steel-looking shaft (listed as graphite/steel mix in some specs, but it feels very much like a normal steel shaft), and a rubber grip.

The head itself is a double-wide blade style, which basically means it’s like a blade that has been stretched back to give a bit more forgiveness and stability. If you’re coming from a full mallet, this feels a bit more compact, but not as skinny as a classic blade. The alignment is pretty simple: a single white line on a black head, which is easy to see at address. No busy graphics, no wild shapes. Just a flat, wide face with a clear line.

Specs-wise, you’re looking at 3° of loft, a 70° lie angle, and a uniflex shaft, which is standard stuff for a putter. It comes in multiple lengths and head styles, but for this review, I’m only talking about the 33" Double Wide. The putter is made in China, which is pretty common now, and it comes with a 2-year manufacturer warranty. The Amazon product page lists a 4.8/5 rating from a few hundred reviews, and honestly, after using it, that rating feels fair, even if I wouldn’t call it perfect.

In practice, what this all means is: you’re buying a simple, heavier-feeling putter from a big name (Callaway/Odyssey) with a soft insert and a basic but effective setup. No adjustable hosel, no moveable weights. If you like to tinker with settings, this is not the club for you. If you just want to unbox it, cut the plastic, and go roll putts, that’s exactly what it’s built for. It’s very much “grab it and play” rather than a tech toy.